Tournament, Table Question, and a Teaching Moment

A Little Extra at the Summer Table

Last month I shared a summer table tip about asking about table rules when you sit down at a new game. Mountain Mahjong on Facebook shared a video summary of a conversation she had with Rita from the National Mah Jongg League — a few really good points, but number 4 stopped me because it speaks directly to what I shared last month.

Here's the full video: Watch here

And here's a summary of #4:

The National Mah Jongg League establishes the rules, but players determine the consequences when someone breaks them. The NMJL sets the standard so we all have a common foundation for play — but the League isn't sitting at your kitchen table telling you how to handle it when a rule gets broken during a friendly game.

That's your group's call.

When someone makes an error in a casual game, you can choose to catch it, let them correct it, and move on. In games with more experienced players, it's worth agreeing ahead of time how you'll handle rules and their consequences. The key distinction: there's a difference between changing a rule and choosing how your group handles the consequence of breaking it. Being gracious when someone makes a mistake does not mean the rule itself has changed.

If you want to become a stronger player, it's worth learning both the rule AND the consequence typically associated with breaking it.

My First Tournament — August 15th

August 15th found me playing in my first Mah Jongg tournament. A full day, 8 rounds, 32 games. Wooo-sah!

It was exciting, anxiety-raising, fun, and a definite will-do-again. My overall score for the day was 95. The high scorer came in around 300+. Around lunchtime, I heard the East at my first table — a longtime tournament player — say she's happy if she scores a hundred for the day. That helped me realize I had done pretty well for my first tournament.

But something else really interesting happened.

There were 82 people in that room — other tournament directors, experienced Easts, and even some considered Mah Jongg "experts" or "celebrities." And from the very first table, a seating arrangement question came up that bothered me all day.

I shared it via video in a public Facebook group — you can see my post here: View my post and video

In the video, I reference Mah Jongg Made Easy, which designates only the East seat position — no others are mentioned or illustrated. In NMJL Mah Jongg, the winds have no bearing on the game other than East's position, unlike Hong Kong Mahjong where they do. I also reference Wright-Patterson's book, which lists seat winds in the E-S-W-N order. My full question and reference materials are shown in the video.

I got a response from Michele Frizzell herself. It's a public group, so you can see my post — but unless you're on Facebook, you won't be able to see her answer. So I'm sharing it here in full:

"Most Westerners misunderstand the wind to seat assignments at the table because our compass follows magnetic North and we navigate by land. The rotation we use is North-East-South-West.

Mah Jongg originated in China so we use their compass when playing the game, not ours. They navigate by the stars so they look up. East is the Dealer (Player 1), to their right is South (Player 2), to their right is West (Player 3), and to their right is North (Player 4). Turns are taken in this order as well.

In Asian variants, the winds are functional; in American Mah Jongg they are largely procedural and traditional.

mahjlife.com/wiki/seat-assignments-and-turn-order-article-170 #MAHJLIFEWIKI #MahJonggMadeClear"

— Michele Frizzell

I thought I was going to have to issue a correction to all of my students. What I'm issuing instead is a heads-up — in case this comes up at an American Mah Jongg game you attend.

Lastly on this topic, I found a great illustrations on Tom Sloper's site that explains the seats in NMJL vs other variants. Remember, in Mah Jongg Made Easy, the only seat designated for NMJL is East. Visit here and so search the page (Ctrl+F) for "seat".

Play on the Patio — New Dates

I had to keep my schedule open to have some beach, yum and fun with my nephews, so new POTP dates are up now — let's enjoy the last few weeks of pleasant temperatures together!

👉 See the new dates here

Until soon,

~ Roanne

© 2026 MahJonggdotClub

All rights reserved